Monday, September 01, 2014
   
Text Size

Search our Site or Google

Even Gold Experts Fooled by Bullion-ETF's

Articles & Blogs - Gold Commentary

User Rating: / 302
PoorBest 

Given the amount of time I spend on my own writing (and the research that entails), I don't spend as much time reading what other commentators are saying about the precious metals sector as I used to. However, I was doing a little poking around when an article by Adam Hamilton caught my eye: GLD Conspiracy Theories.


Having considerable respect for the work of Mr. Hamilton, I decided it was certainly worth my time to see what he had to say on this issue – given that I have been extremely vocal in expressing my concerns over the legitimacy of these bullion-buying vehicles. I admit to being frankly shocked.


Mr. Hamilton went on a long tirade, looking to belittle those who doubt these funds at every opportunity, during which time he constructed no less than eleven sub-arguments – which he supposedly rebutted. And after going to the time and effort to construct and rebut those eleven “arguments” he never mentioned the bullion-banks once.


I simply have neither the time or desire to respond to all of Mr. Hamilton's specific “counter-arguments”. I encourage those who want to know everything said about this to go straight to the source (in the link above). I submit, however, that the vast majority of these arguments are what are known as “straw men”.


This is a commonly used technique in faulty arguments. Someone wishing to establish his own position attempts to do so through “rebutting” the arguments of those with opposing views. However, instead of choosing the strongest arguments of his opponents, he chooses the weakest ones – or simply invents his own “arguments” to rebut. This is what Hamilton has done here.


Those familiar with my own writing know that I have written several commentaries challenging the legitimacy of bullion-ETF's without ever using any of the supposed “arguments” from Mr. Hamilton's commentary. I'm not saying that no one is using any of those arguments, however several of the eleven sub-arguments are certainly topics I have never seen discussed before.


Let me try to incorporate some of what he has said into my own analysis, and I'll let readers decide for themselves if his views on this subject detract from my own analysis. Mr. Hamilton points out that GLD was founded by the World Gold Council, which, itself is “an industry association funded by the world's leading gold miners”.


I will briefly point out that Jim Sinclair (and others) are convinced that several of these “leading gold miners” were involved in gold-hedging and gold-derivative agreements which directly served the interests of the anti-gold cabal – by providing them with countless tons of gold to dump onto the market which had not even been dug out of the ground. However, I will go no further down this line of reasoning since it is not necessary to discredit those running GLD in order to cast doubt on the fund, itself.


Since Mr. Hamilton never talked about the bullion-banks, he also never mentioned the huge “custodian agreements” which GLD has entered into with the bullion-banks – the same bullion-banks who are the largest “shorts” in the history of commodities. Since Mr. Hamilton never thought to ask this question, I'll ask it myself: why didn't the gold miners who founded GLD simply choose to hold and store their own bullion?


There are only a very limited number of possibilities here, so I will try to cover the bases. The most obvious explanation strongly supports my own position: the bullion banks offered to supply GLD with infinite amounts of bullion for a minimal cost – and essentially no profit to themselves. As I have pointed out on other occasions, it is difficult for me to decide which aspect of this premise is the most ludicrous: that the largest shorts in history would create a trading vehicle to help longs enter the market, or that bankers would do anything for virtually no profit for themselves.


We know that the bullion-banks are performing this huge service virtually free of charge, since if they were taking a large profit for themselves out of this arrangement there could be no possible advantage to using these bullion-banks – since GLD could hold/store bullion more cheaply, itself, if the banks were gouging it on the custodian agreements.


What other possible reason could the gold miners who founded GLD have for choosing the bullion-bank shorts as “custodians” for their gold? Is it because these banks represented the safest storage option for GLD unit-holders? Hardly. These same bankers have a long history of bullion fraud. The most recent example of this was when Morgan Stanley recently paid millions in damages for simply pretending to buy bullion – on behalf of its own clients (see “Morgan Stanley pays damages for Precious Metals Fraud”).


Is Mr. Hamilton really naïve enough to believe that bankers who would cheat their own clients would not do the same to small, gold and silver investors – who are not their own clients? The whole reason these bankers (mostly U.S. bankers) are caught in one fraud-scheme after another is that they know they never have to worry about criminal prosecution for their misdeeds and the fines levied against them are always less than the profits they make on those schemes.


Thus, since GLD did not choose to use the bullion-banks as custodians for safety, then unless they offered to buy and store GLD's “bullion” far cheaper than anyone else, what other reason could GLD have for using the bullion-banks? The only other suggestion I can come up with is that the gold miners who founded GLD have had such a long and cosy relationship with these bullion-banks that they simply never considered any other arrangement.


Whether the bullion-banks are being used because they offered subsidized rates for storage, or because they are such good friends with the miners involved, Mr. Hamilton's assurances about the founders of GLD do nothing to address my own concerns.


One relevant issue that Mr. Hamilton does raise is the issue of audits. He proclaims himself to be an accountant, notes that GLD is “audited” - and considers the case closed. In fact, I had another accountant take exactly this stance in criticizing my position on bullion-ETF's. I point out to Mr. Hamilton the same thing I pointed out to this other accountant: the bullion-banks have two, enormous gold (and silver) obligations – the massive custodian agreements and the equally massive, in-house short positions.


Only ½ of these holdings are ever audited: the GLD holdings, while the only backing these bullion-banks have ever demonstrated for their short positions is the tiny portion of that amount they have to post as collateral for their position. The two holdings have never been simultaneously audited. Half an audit is obviously no better than no audit at all.


All that has ever been established is that the bullion banks have enough bullion to cover either their short positions or the custodian agreements. If these bankers had to choose between defaulting on their own short positions – which would permanently discredit them in commodity markets, or defaulting on their custodian agreements (and pay a small fine), which course of action would these bankers be most likely to take?


This brings me to what is clearly the most bizarre part of Mr. Hamilton's defense of GLD. Among my most powerful arguments against the bullion-ETF's is that they perfectly serve the interests of the bullion-banks. These funds have soaked up tens of billions of investor dollars in the precious metals sector. Had these funds never existed, while some of that money may never have entered the sector, obviously most of it would have been used to buy real bullion, or have been invested in the commodity-producers – the miners.


I remind readers that these same bankers who were leveraging their own paper by 30:1 would certainly never hesitate to leverage their bullion a mere 2:1. If the bullion-banks were merely pretending to hold bullion for these funds, then instantly these “bullion-ETF's” become the bankers' biggest weapon in suppressing the prices of gold and silver, through diluting the money entering this sector nearly by half.


This entire argument completely escapes Adam Hamilton, indeed, he actually attempts to argue the exact opposite point. He strongly asserts that if GLD was found to be all “paper” or simply mostly paper that this would be damaging to the positions of “longs” who were holding real bullion.


I find this argument completely unfathomable and without merit. GLD is now (supposedly) one of the largest holdings of gold on the planet. If this supposed stockpile of gold was found to be non-existent, then the value of the real bullion held by investors does not go down, it goes up. This is simple supply/demand dynamics.


If GLD is fraudulent, then this immediately means that gold stockpiles (i.e. “supply”) are much smaller than believed. This shifts the demand curve to the left, meaning higher gold prices at every level of demand. While Mr. Hamilton is an accountant, he is clearly not an economist.


I began reading his article anxious to see if I had overlooked anything in my own analysis of this issue, and fully prepared to amend my views if a genuine gold-bug like Adam Hamilton had come up with any factors I had not previously considered.


Instead, I remain more convinced than ever of the illegitimate nature of most bullion-ETF's (as I always acknowledge, there are smaller funds which do buy and hold their own bullion). While Mr. Hamilton only briefly mentioned silver, I cannot engage in a discussion of the legitimacy of bullion-ETF's without reminding readers of a previous discovery: that all the silver “held” by SLV (and others) is for sale – as part of official inventories.


Obviously, the founders of SLV (and the bullion-banks lurking in the shadows) cannot claim to be “holding” over 400 million ounces of silver for their unit-holders, while slapping a “for sale” sticker on every bar – meaning that anyone with enough money could buy every ounce of silver “held” by SLV today (see “Your ETF-Silver is For Sale”). Some “custodian agreement”!


For investors who want a position in precious metals, buy real gold or silver, or buy into a safe bullion-ETF. Do not buy GLD or SLV unless you trust bankers. And do not rely upon Adam Hamilton for reassurances in this regard. For whatever reason, he has demonstrated an enormous “blind spot” on this issue.


There are many legitimate reasons to doubt the validity of large, bullion-ETF's – and as of today none of those concerns have yet to be addressed.

Trackback(0)
Comments (1)Add Comment
JsJ
...
written by JsJ, December 17, 2009
I agree that I have found his writing good in the past. I also think that he is mistaken, and not actually part of the (as yet unproven) deception going on with the GLD and SLV funds.

I wouldn't mind trading GLD, and I own it in my "fantasy portfolio", but I don't and most likely won't own any shares of GLD or SLV for anything remotely resembling a "long haul".

Write comment
You must be logged in to post a comment. Please register if you do not have an account yet.

busy

Latest Commentary

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 6
  • 7
  • 8
  • 9
  • 10
  • 11
  • 12

Latest Comments

Disclaimer:

BullionBullsCanada.com is not a registered investment advisor - Stock information is for educational purposes ONLY. Bullion Bulls Canada does not make "buy" or "sell" recommendations for any company. Rather, we seek to find and identify Canadian companies who we see as having good growth potential. It is up to individual investors to do their own "due diligence" or to consult with their financial advisor - to determine whether any particular company is a suitable investment for themselves.

Login Form

how soon after taking metformin can i get pregnant levitra plus legal in england can clomid cause early menopause buy flovent no prescription fast delivery lov cost brafix generic pills for levitra super active buy levothroid for daily use hcg overseas pharmacy viagra canadian pharmacy buy prazosin mg online current price cialis professional optimmune for dogs uk vasotec 20 mg efectos secundarios buy betapace generic levlen buy canada trimox order in the us prednisone low cost order xenical next day can i get revia where to buy alli in toronto diflucan 100 mg candida entocort and drinking alcohol amoxicillin canada pharmacy diabecon no prescription canada why has triamterene been discontinued diclofenac generic gel cialis online to buy online pharmacy courses in pakistan pamelor side effects migraines legal buy deltasone online canada buy 160 mg viagra tablets alcohol and azithromycin chlamydia low price lipitor uk side effects of levitra tablets long term side effects of dapoxetine phenergan medication interactions can you buy forzest over the counter in germany serophene mg buy buy actos from canada betamethasone tablets dose american lithium minerals corp buy abilify 2mg canada prescription parenteral drugs india ltd goa safe buy snovitra super power online buy furosemide online from usa indocin dosage for migraine generic for avapro medication non prescription minocin pharmacy motilium instants review tretinoin cream usp 0.1 reviews side effects of compazine suppository best pharmacy to order nizoral generic voltaren ophthalmic increasing fertility in women over 40 cheap viagra melbourne what does lamisil pills treat viagra sublingual tablets side effects side effects of drinking on antibiotics generic finax cost viagra plus nitrates ordering atorlip pharmacy canadian better than levitra canadian drug stores ratings what does viagra do to a healthy male generic tretinoin 0,05 for sale on line cymbalta online in uk benadryl tablets online side effects of stopping sarafem cialis without script viagra without prescriptions approved alavert allergy orally disintegrating tablets what does dilantin erythromycin birth control online mexico prednisone 20 mg. medication lady era drugstore.com avapro medication dose metformin cancer research differin gel online pharmacy can you get cleocin gel most reliable place to buy dapoxetine online where can i buy cialis tablets allopurinol discounted can you buy adalat pills acheter aspirin pas cher minocin coupons global aspirin sales clonidine discount voucher betnovate-c skin cream in india pharmacie kirchberg buy viagra 50 mg buy online viagra uk triamterene hctz weight loss paroxetine next day shipping flagyl alcohol consumption buy clozaril hong kong bactroban brand order buy famvir overseas donde comprar aciphex best prices for aricept accredited online pharmacy schools alesse echeck diclofenac sodium price uk canadian pharmacy online abilify buy indocin in india online what is enalapril maleate 5mg used for what is duphalac pilex ointment use how to use alli in spanish vantin side effects long term use pharmacy mexico viagra professional v-gel price india buy differin without a script is nitroglycerin tablets explosive cytotec online store blood pressure medicine called bystolic erythromycin benzoyl peroxide topical gel for acne why is there a shortage of tadapox noroxin pharmacy coupons zithromax alcohol side effects isoniazid mg buy glucophage from canada how to take tegretol retard estrogen blockers for sale accutane side effects dry eyes how much does advair diskus 500 50 cost buy tretinoin gel canada buy zanaflex pills what is the generic for zyrtec mentat over the counter synthroid without zanaflex maximum daily dose what is famvir used to treat disfuncion erectil tratamiento jovenes cefixime purchase online buy generic apcalis sx online top 10 online uroxatral sites glipizide and metformin combination buy sustiva with paypal amoxil and birth control pills buy levitra without script norvasc medication information how to take diclofenac gel mg value generic pharmacy review tadalafil overdose brand avapro 300mg buy roxithromycin uses medication cialis otc thailand medicine buy levitra plus online aarp prior authorization form medicare clomid canada no prescription what is cleocin made of apcalis jelly diclofenac banned in india cheap cafergot 40 mg list of tesco stores selling tetracycline buy capoten no prescription generic equivalent for celebrex ventolin hfa aer ad buy voltaren from mexico online cheap diclofenac gel usa m 30 blue pill side effects revatio pronunciation disfuncion erectil sintomas lamictal now where generic propecia manufactured brahmi doctors online trandate costco how long do lansoprazole take to work price allegra d walgreens is cephalexin ok to take when pregnant purchase maxalt 5 mg generic form of exelon protonix pills online in the india online cealis that accepts paypal omnicef user reviews where can you get prednisone cheap colchicine 0.5 mg aciclovir tabletas de 400mg dosis lopressor prices adalat generic release date generic actoplus met 15 500 500mg lamisil online pharmacy uk ordering protonix on line indinavir weight gain buy alligator clips hair bows overstock drugstore coupon retailmenot where to buy clonidine ointment how much does actos cost at walmart cialis super active reviews vgr 100 medicine gemfibrozil peersription us can you buy amitriptyline online discount canadian comprar metformina buy periactin dose levitra buy singapore buspar and alcohol cravings non prescription erectile dysfunction meds how much does a toradol injection cost is generic lexapro available taking too many aleve pills actos prix en pharmacie en france optimmune eye ointment for humans what does digoxin do to heart rate can you order prednisolone online pharmacy retin-a 0,025 delivery uk genuine lipitor best price cost of cialis super active generic arjuna safe wellbutrin uk prescription no without phexin italiano Purchase lexapro 10 mg can you really buy xanax online remeron soltab for insomnia trileptal roche precio argentina cipro class action lawsuit 2010 is there a drug comparative to tadacip anafranil online in us female cialis without insurance remeron 15 mg tablets best place to buy prinivil nitroglycerin ointment shelf life low dosage of accutane canada drugs evista with prescription what does dutasteride do zestril without script does nolvadex make you gain weight himplasia drug schedule overnight pharmacy4u coupon mifepristone buy in canada how to order robaxin online pharmacy brand levitra from canada deltasone no prescription compare prices generic differin gel prometrium supplier in uk no prescription minocycline sale sports medicine advisor low back pain glycomet 100mg buy fast motilium deleviery buying reglan for dogs naprosyn sr 1000 mg 1000mg norfloxcin iscrizione newsletter viagra 100 mg prednisone side effects of motrin in babies what is better than protonix unisom mail order india online cholestoplex purchase cialis en ligne port gratuit generic name for cafergot buy clonidine visa uk pharmacies online that sell flagyl nitroglycerin for men in usa where to get generic lipitor sustiva retail price trazodone desyrel drug information best place to buy mentat prandin generic 2013 drugs generic baclofen tablet what is the medicine aldactone for aceon drugstore.com dipyridamole online legally what does wellbutrin do for depression buy micardis pills can you abuse zanaflex cheapest keflex in the uk buy glyset mg suprax generic suspension cheap kamagra online uk back pain pills otc fucidin tablets 250 mg can i make lamisil cytotec nombre generico sale dramamine adalat 10 mg sublinguale buy amitriptyline with no script alphagan pills sweat buy levitra online australia no prescription health benefits of lasuna elavil 10 mg weight gain indian pharmacy albenza where to buy metformin tablets generic paxil cr reviews cialis no prescription online pharmacy is generic anastrozole as good as arimidex what does phenergan brand names hyaluronic acid reviews joints citalopram 10mg tablets withdrawal online pharmacy no prescription needed cleocin what are the side effects of taking prevacid buy viagra with a check can purchase clomid online where to get tetracycline for rats avodart generic name azulfidine women buy buy ginette-35 online india alfumet fluconazol what is lamictal used for in children buy buspar online pharmacy risperdal canada generic synthroid mg order bayer 20 pink pill toprol xl from usa buy live caterpillars online billig famvir online kaufen order birth control online can i order rosuvastatin no prescription in the usa can i get high off doxycycline hyclate buy mentat hong kong how to order azulfidine online zetia medication side effects buy augmentin online no prescription asthma treatment guidelines can you buy flovent online pharmacy ordering furosemide mexico where can i get some plendil cheap propranolol 10 mg how much is zithromax without insurance generic bentyl overnite shipping efectos de la sertralina y el alcohol legal buy sinequan online canada where can i buy viagra safely online proscar tablets propecia wellbutrin reviews for adhd online pharmacy uk celadrin bystolic side effects long term use yasmin pills philippines buy actos with drugs is there a shortage of accutane forzest in canada safe place order mircette cardura 20mg tab discount canadian pharmacy zyvox premarin horses names of aspirin medication half price speman is there a generic for augmentin cheap us buy calander buy unisom overseas what is diltiazem for how much will cardizem cost venlor non perscription countries online prescriptions in australia cialis canadian alternative zu tadalafil how to take liquid clomid after steroids buy seroflo online no prescription us cephalexin common side effects insulin sensitivity factor cheap accutane sale acne cytotec on line in the usa doxycycline 500 mg prices what is metformin drugs yasmin birth control price in canada buy cipla tadalafil india ceftin price periactin delivery himplasia prices allopurinol gout acute attack side effects of thyroid medication being too high pamelor medication tinnitus lopid now nizagara price india citalopram and wellbutrin combination solubilidad ciprofloxacina clorhidrato billig viagra plus online kaufen como usar alli purchasing cordarone online orlistat 60 mg capsules buy grifulvin v lowest price is it legal to buy viagra online in the us relion ventolin hfa inhaler 8g 60 puffs allegra d generic over the counter part 120 drug and alcohol testing program medicine called neurontin purchase januvia pills can you order periactin canadian propecia arimidex for sale online lopid 600 mg tab benemid without a prescription what is the lowest dose of lipitor available buy dipyridamole online canada doxycycline hyclate for acne reviews brand name sarafem online renagel mail order india canadian health insurance association levlen ed acne lioresal intratecal onde comprar buying doxycycline in peru buy estrace pills can allegra make you gain weight xenical online mexico buy generic levothyroxine prescription avalide medicine do i need a prescription for metformin order zestril tablets buy lamisil with como comprar cytotec zocor buy online ireland list of tesco stores selling seroflo colchicine side effects alcohol can you get tulasi how long to take fucidin is it safe to order accutane online approved best ed drug for diabetics claravis coupon how can you get promethazine codeine syrup ropinirole xl half life buy viagra online denmark buy celexa 100mg online discount lipitor online atorvastatin wellbutrin xl prices what is serevent used for uk buy provera without prescription where to purchase innopran xl water pills side effects cramps buy cialis 20 mg tablet how to get differin on line prescription medicines code of practice authority familiarisation seminar levlen delivery buy albenza online generic tapeworm motrin 800 high blood pressure generic nizagara india brand name combivent online grifulvin v women buy pariet tablets online where can i get acai berry in south africa buy genuine cytotec uk remeron lowest price where to get propecia online mobic tablets 15mg spc what is the drug olanzapine used for erythromycin in pregnancy kamagra gold for purchase buy augmentin online at canada pharmacy levitra uk boots atorlip-20 generic wikipedia drugs cialis online american pharmacy finpecia without script hypertension medication hyzaar where to buy cheap generic plavix can you order purinethol cheapest liv in the uk most trusted rx viagra sublingual drug oversea what does asacol trazodone usage clomid to buy in the canada without a prescription is viagra over the counter available in canada what is rimadyl 25mg buy norvasc no prescription viagra reviews forum pharmacy generic reviews on yasmin sumycin drug store online viagra sent from europe buy shatavari kalpa doxycycline antibiotic ear infections himplasia pills sweat best diltiazem prices ibuprofen 400 mg tablets side effects best site for atarax betapace medicine children where diabecon after accutane acne returns is there a class action lawsuit against lipitor can you buy birth control pills in mexico baclofen 25 mg buy prescription painkillers online no prescription prescription drug kamagra safe to buy generic sinequan from canada cozaar on line for sale no script comprar elocon pela internet lasix injection for dogs levitra consegna rapida cialis sublingual now co uk buy cheap topamax using pay pal online order grifulvin v where to levitra professional drugstore online drug reverse and cure levaquin side effects vente de dilantin au quebec pravachol pharmacy coupons what dosages does zyprexa come in estrace generic cream viagra plus maximum dosage how much is doxycycline cost can you buy viagra sublingual in ireland best site get nitrofurantoin class a drugs list uk buy artane pills mail order prednisone imdb we need to talk about kevin flonase nasal spray instructions has triamterene been discontinued lamisil price comparison zyloprim shortage generic trileptal us online pharmacy tretinoin 0,025 is differin legal in uk what is the correct dosage of phenergan obagi medical tretinoin cream usp 0.05 paxil 10mg reviews suprax tablets 400mg sibutramine alternatives generic carbozyne uk paypal lithium carbonate price history is it illegal to order generic minipress purchase ditropan in usa do you need rx gasex finast canada head office comprar metformina 850 mg flagyl antibiotic information alternatives to prednisone for dog allergies viagra in canada cost homemade medicine for abortion buspar pas cher italie generic benicar alternatives valacyclovir uk price